Bluey is browsing through a toy catalog, circling her desired items with a red marker. Bandit enters the room with a pile of toys to put away, accidentally stepping on a toy echidna. Bingo walks in, claiming she’s bored, which prompts Bandit to exclaim, “How can you be bored with this many toys!” He complains about the kids not putting their toys away, and Bluey responds by asking him to buy more toys, including a TommyTeddy, Starlight Unicorse, and a rainbow Boobear. Bandit refuses and attempts to put a basket of toys in the cupboard, but ends up getting buried under an avalanche of toys. This leads him to declare that it’s time for a chuck-out.
Bandit and Chilli set up two baskets, labeled “keep” and “chuck,” and begin sorting through the toys. As they sort, every toy ends up in the “keep” basket, except for a banana and a giraffe, which temporarily land in the “chuck” basket. Eventually, only Mr. Monkeyjocks, a monkey wearing jocks, remains in the “chuck” basket. Bandit comments that they never play with him, so they need to show him that Mr. Monkeyjocks is special if they want to keep him. Chilli warns that he’ll regret this decision. The kids then start playing with Mr. Monkeyjocks, replacing Bandit with him in various scenarios, such as reading the paper, sitting at the breakfast table, and even shooting Bandit with a ball cannon at an indoor playground. On the way home, Bandit “lets” Mr. Monkeyjocks drive, and when they arrive, Mr. Monkeyjocks has taken Bandit’s sunglasses and somehow married Chilli.
As the episode progresses, Bandit becomes Mr. Monkeyjocks’ butler, and Mr. Monkeyjocks takes over the kids’ room, replacing Bluey’s bed covers and taking the other toys’ clothes. Bluey gets fed up and says someone should find somewhere else to live, prompting Mr. Monkeyjocks to kick the kids out of the house. Chilli questions his harsh decision, and he kicks her out too. The family sits on the front steps, discussing Mr. Monkeyjocks’ cheeky behavior, and decides to ask if they can sleep in the backyard. They discover that Mr. Monkeyjocks has gone mad with power, putting all the toys in the “chuck” basket except for himself. However, his head soon droops, and Bluey notices he looks a bit bored. The kids “listen” to Mr. Monkeyjocks and learn that he’s come to realize that “when you get everything you want, nothing is special anymore.” He now wants to make someone else feel special. The episode ends with the family trying again to sort through their toys, this time donating some to those in need. The episode concludes with a sick child in the hospital being overjoyed when his mother gives him a Mr. Monkeyjocks as a gift.
