Bluey and Bingo are getting ready for bed, and their parents remind them that Easter is tomorrow. Bingo is worried that the Easter Bunny might forget about them, just like last year. Her parents show her a letter from the Easter Bunny explaining why he was late, and they reassure her that they won’t be forgotten this time. After their parents leave, Bingo asks Bluey if she thinks the Easter Bunny will remember them, and Bluey replies, “Yeah. I do.” Bluey falls asleep, but Bingo stays awake for a little while longer.
The next morning, the girls wake up and immediately check their Easter pouches, only to find them empty. However, they notice a box in Bluey’s pouch and a letter B in Bingo’s. Bluey puts the two together and they run to the letterbox, where they find a Chatterbox with a sticker of an egg wearing a chef’s hat. Bluey thinks this means the eggs are in the kitchen, so they run in to investigate. Their parents are preparing food, and the girls search through the drawers until Bingo notices that the magnets on the fridge are arranged to form a large egg. They look inside, but instead of eggs, they find a kiwi. They take the kiwi to their dad and ask if there’s chocolate inside, but there isn’t. Bluey keeps thinking and runs to the playroom with Bingo, where they check under the kiwi rug but don’t find anything. Bingo notices an arrow on the rug pointing to the garden, so they head outside.
In the garden, the girls split up and start searching. Bingo finds a sandcastle in the sandpit, and Bluey notices that the pointsettia flowers are arranged in straight lines. They head up to the balcony and see that the flowers are shaped like a castle, which reminds Bingo of the sandpit. They dig under the sandcastle and find toilet paper with eggs on it, which leads them to the bathroom. However, they don’t find anything in the main bathroom, so they decide to check their dad’s bathroom. Bandit is using the facilities, and the girls are hesitant to go in, but Bluey finds the courage to enter and searches for clues. She finds a shape drawn on the mirror, which she reproduces on a piece of paper and shows to Bingo. Bingo recognizes the shape as their stained window, but when they check their bedroom, they don’t find anything. The girls start to feel discouraged, with Bingo blaming herself for being forgettable and Bluey blaming herself for not finding the eggs. However, they quickly realize that they’re not forgettable and that they worked together to solve the clues. Just then, Bluey notices footprints in glitter leading from their drawings the night before, and they run to the study. They push the yoga ball out of the way and find a basket of treats, chocolate, and books under the desk. The Easter Bunny remembered them after all.
